The cottonwoods along the Avonkarea stood thick where the Tomichi emptied into it, their pale trunks crowding close like old women gathered to whisper. We had ridden this passage many times, Ouray and I, leading the Tabeguache, the shade of these trees a familiar greeting on the long trail between the Uncompahgre and the Cochetopa. The spring melt had swollen both creeks so that they sang loud enough to swallow the sound of our horses' hooves on the soft earth, and it was this singing, I think, that kept us from hearing the animal before it burst from the brush.

It came crashing out of the willows not ten paces ahead, a white thing with blotches the color of rusted iron, heavy-bodied and wide between the horns, its eyes rolling white as it scrambled ahead of us. My horse shied, and I tightened my knees against her ribs, steadying her with a hand along her neck. The creature turned toward us, its wet nose working the air, then turned and lumbered through the cottonwoods. Behind it, in the dappled shadows, I saw others. Three, then five, then more than I could count without stopping to look. They lay in the cool dirt among the roots, their great jaws working slowly, sideways, the way elk chew but with none of an elk's alertness. They watched us with a dull, unbothered patience as we passed among them, tilting their heavy heads to follow our movement, some rising to their feet with a groan and stepping carefully between the pale trunks.

Longhorn cattle. I had seen them before, penned behind fences of split rail, bawling and stamping in their own filth. But never here. Never on this side of the dividing of the great waters, where the land still belonged to us by treaty and by the memory of every Tabeguache who had ever drawn breath. Their presence among these familiar cottonwoods was like finding a stranger asleep in your own lodge, not threatening, exactly, but deeply, unsettling and wrong.

Ouray said nothing. He rode ahead of me, his back straight, his eyes moving over the animals with that careful stillness that meant he was reading everything, the condition of their hides, the way they grazed, what their presence here meant and the question of who brought them. I watched his shoulders and saw the quiet gathering of his thoughts. I held my own silence and followed.

We emerged from the cottonwoods into the open flat where the two creeks joined, and I pulled my horse to a stop.

A cabin stood where our camp had always been.

It was a rough thing, built of logs still wearing their bark, the chinking between them pale with mud and grass. A thin thread of smoke rose from a stone chimney at its far end. Before it, spreading across the flat and up the gentle rise beyond, hundreds of the white and rust-colored cattle grazed in the new spring grass, their bodies dotting the green like scattered stones. The sight of so many was startling, a herd to rival the elk that gathered in the Cochetopa, though without any of their wild grace.

A man stood beside the cabin with an ax in his hands. He had been chopping wood; a scattering of fresh-split pieces lay around a stump, and a stack of rounds waited their turn. He paused mid-swing when we appeared, and looked at us.

I watched his hands. They did not move toward the pistol on his hip. They did not reach for the long rifle that leaned against the cabin wall within easy distance. He simply set the ax down, straightened his back, and turned to face us fully. He stood still.

There was something in his face.

I had learned to read the faces of white men the way one reads weather, not the words they spoke, which were often smoke, but the things behind their eyes where the truth lived. In Agent Caldwell's face I had always seen a man wrestling with himself, a tightness around the mouth that spoke of promises he knew he could not keep. In the faces of soldiers, I saw fear and arrogance dressed as authority. In the faces of prospectors, I saw hunger so deep it had consumed everything else in them.

But this man's face was different. Beneath the thick whiskers, weathered brown by wind and altitude, his eyes held something I could not immediately name. They were clear. That was the nearest word I could find for it, clear, the way a creek runs clear over white stones when nothing upstream has troubled it. There was no guilt in those eyes, no calculation, no pity masking contempt. He looked at us the way the land itself looked at us: without judgment, without agenda, simply acknowledging what was there.

He smiled. It was not the nervous, too-wide smile of men who feared us, nor the thin-lipped courtesy of officials. It was easy and unhurried, and he nodded once as we approached.

"Chief Ouray." His voice was low and steady, carrying the rough edges of a man who spent his days speaking to horses and open sky. Then his gaze moved to me, and he reached up and scooped the hat from his head, holding it against his chest. "Chipeta."

He said my name as though it were a word he respected, not a curiosity to roll around on his tongue.

Ouray nodded but did not speak. Behind us, I could hear the murmur of our people emerging from the cottonwoods, the creak of travois and the soft voices of children asking questions about the strange animals.

"I'm Alonzo Hartman," the man said, replacing his hat and gesturing toward the herd with a broad, unhurried sweep of his hand. "Rode in here last December with these cattle." He paused, and something moved at the corner of his mouth, a kind of private amusement. "Reckon these are your cattle," he chuckled. "The agency hired me to bring this bunch an' look after them for you."

He did not seem troubled by Ouray's silence. I had watched many white men grow uneasy when Ouray did not respond immediately, their words spilling faster to fill the space he left open, as though silence were a thing to be feared. But Alonzo Hartman simply waited. He stood with his weight settled evenly on both feet, his hands loose at his sides, and he watched Ouray with the patience of a man accustomed to the rhythms of animals and seasons, things that could not be hurried.

Ouray's gaze moved slowly across the grazing herd. His face gave nothing away, but I knew the thoughts moving behind his eyes. Cattle meant the agency believed we would stay here. Cattle meant someone in that faraway stone city had decided our future would be measured in livestock rather than hunting grounds. But cattle also meant food for our people, and Ouray was a man who weighed every offering against the cost of refusing it.

"Lord o' mercy," Alonzo said suddenly, his eyes widening as though he had just remembered something important. "I've forgot my manners. Light and sit a spell. I got coffee."

Ouray turned to the people gathered at the edge of the cottonwoods. He spoke quietly, directing them to make camp further to the north along the creek where the ground was level and the water ran easy. Then he swung down from his horse, and I followed.

We sat on rounds of wood that Alonzo pulled near the cabin door. He disappeared inside and returned with two tin cups, steam curling from their rims, and the bitter smell of the black drink reaching me before the cup did.

"You picked the best place," Ouray said as Alonzo placed the cup in his hands.

It was the first thing Ouray had said, and the words carried more than their surface meaning. This flat where the creeks met had been our stopping place for as long as any elder could remember, good water, good grass, shelter from wind. That a white man had recognized its worth did not surprise me, but the fact that Ouray acknowledged it aloud to this stranger told me something had shifted in him. Some door had opened, however slightly.

I took the cup Alonzo offered me and brought it to my lips. The liquid was dark and scalding and tasted of something burned. I swallowed, but my face must have betrayed me, for Alonzo caught the small tightening at the corners of my mouth before I could hide it.

"You don't like coffee much, do you, ma'am," he said. There was no mockery in it, only the gentle observation of a man paying attention. "Let me bring you some tea."

He returned with a second cup, this one lighter in color, fragrant with something herbal that I did not recognize but that soothed the bitterness the coffee had left behind. I nodded my thanks, and he sat down across from us, settling onto his own round of wood as though he had all the time the mountains could offer.

They talked. The winter, which had been among the harshest I could remember, Alonzo described snow up to the bellies of his horses and nights so cold the creek froze solid and he and "his boys", as he like to call them had to chop holes in the ice. "It hurried us some to find grass enough under the snow to keep them alive. We had to push them up onto the south-facing slopes where they could paw through the snow."

They spoke of the grass coming in, how the south-facing slopes greened first, how the cattle had thinned through the cold months but were filling out now. Ouray asked questions about the animals', and Alonzo answered each one directly, without embellishment, without the careful hedging I had come to expect from every white man who sat across from my husband.

I watched them both, my tea warming my hands, and I saw something I had not seen in Ouray for longer than I wished to count. The tightness in his jaw was loosening. The weight that bent his shoulders was easing, if only by a measure. He leaned forward as he listened. He asked questions, the way a man does when his curiosity has outrun his caution. He answered Alonzo's questions in a steady, patient manner.

We did not leave the next morning. Nor the morning after.

For nearly a week, we camped beside Alonzo Hartman's cabin. He took us riding through the herd, pointing out the stronger animals, explaining which cows would calve first, showing Ouray how to read the signs of sickness in their eyes and gait. The men who worked for him, quiet, sun-darkened men who smelled of leather and woodsmoke, tipped their hats when we passed and did not reach for their weapons. They did not stare at our people with the hollow hunger of prospectors or the rigid suspicion of soldiers. They nodded. They moved aside on the trail. One of them showed a group of our boys how to throw a lariat, laughing when the rope landed on nothing, and the boys laughed with him.

I could not explain it. I had no word for the thing that seemed to flow from Alonzo Hartman into the space around him, warming it the way a fire warms a lodge in winter, not by force, but by its simple, steady presence. He was direct. He said what he meant and did not say what he did not mean, and the distance between those two things, which in most white men was as wide as a river, in him was nothing at all.

On the fifth evening, I sat watching Ouray and Alonzo by the fire, their faces lit by the shifting glow, and I saw my husband smile. Not the careful, measured expression he wore at councils, nor the weary half-smile he offered me in our darkest hours. A true smile, unguarded, rising from some deep place that I had feared was gone forever.

I did not know then what name to give this thing growing between them. Only later would I understand that I had witnessed the rarest of gifts in a time of relentless taking, a friendship born not of necessity nor advantage, but of recognition. Two men, from worlds that were trying to destroy each other, who looked across the fire and saw something, someone worth trusting.

And I, who had learned to guard my heart against every white face, felt the same impossible pull, as though the Creator had sent us this man, this Alonzo Hartman, to remind us that even in a world being broken apart, wholeness could still be found in the most unexpected of places.

Advanced Reader Copies of The Arrow and the Setting Sun are available.

If you are interested in reading this novel and providing a review, please contact me for additional information and to get your link to download the ARC.